Which Broadcast Shows Will Break Out On Streaming Next?

(Welcome to my weekly streaming ratings report, the single best guide to what’s popular in streaming TV and what isn’t. I’m the Entertainment Strategy Guy, a former streaming executive who now analyzes business strategy in the entertainment industry. If you were forwarded this email, please subscribe to get these insights each week.)

I was already planning on writing about broadcast TV shows and their streaming viewership this week—because a slew of viewership data points have come out recently on this season’s fall shows—then I saw three different headlines about how older TV shows are putting up big numbers on streaming. So the timing couldn’t be better.

This is old news to my readers, of course, because I’ve been writing about the success of second run and library shows on streaming for years (like literally almost half a decade). And while the streamers have benefitted from this library content for years, they’ve been unable to replicate the success of broadcast sitcoms and procedurals on their platforms, something else I’ve also been warning people about for years!

So we’ll look at the big linear viewership numbers, along with TV’s biggest show in October, the NFL. All that, plus Minions & Monsters on Peacock, a new comedy and a new docu-series on Netflix, Apple’s latest crime thriller, VisionQuest and Tulsa King’s strong holds, Moana’s bad second week, the World Series’ surprisingly resilient ratings, bad news for actors, all the flops, bombs and misses, and a whole lot more.

Let’s dive right in!

(Reminder: The streaming ratings report focuses on the U.S. market and compiles data from Nielsen’s weekly top ten viewership ranks, Luminate’s Top Ten Data, JustWatch and Reelgood interest data, Samba TV household viewership, company datecdotes, Netflix hours viewed data, Google Trends, and IMDb to determine the most popular content. While most data points are current, Nielsen’s data covers the weeks of October 26th to November 1st, 2026.

You can find a link to my terminology here.)

TV – Linear Shows on Streaming

I feel like every couple of years, someone reruns an analysis to show that, actually, someone not named “Kevin Bacon” is actually better connected to other actors than Kevin Bacon and by way less than six degrees. Back in the year 2000, Malcolm Gladwell debunked this idea in his very famous bestseller, The Tipping Point, crowning Rod Steiger as the most connected actor…all of which is to say, this debunking isn’t new. (Maybe it just shows how hard it is to debunk popular notions…)

Similarly, every six months or so, someone writes that library and second run shows with huge catalogues dominate customers’ viewership on broadcast, cable and streaming. Recently, I’ve read a few headlines touting that…old TV shows are all the rage! NCIS! Seinfeld! The Big Bang Theory! In short, if you look at Nielsen’s weekly viewership charts and add all their viewership up, old TV shows are really, really popular.

This trend isn’t new. Seriously, the moment Nielsen started releasing weekly top ten lists, anyone could easily see that older sitcoms like The Office, Seinfeld, and Friends drove lots of viewership on streaming, along with procedurals like NCIS or Grey’s Anatomy. Heck, I even made an acronym for it, F-BOSSS (Friends, The Big Bang Theory, The Office, The Simpsons, Seinfeld and South Park).

Just look at my recap of the top shows in 2025; you can see that acquired TV shows dominate the top of the charts:

Seven of the top eight and thirteen of the 17 shows are all acquired titles. But it’s not older shows dominating the charts; most of the top shows are actually still on the air.

Only seven of the eighteen acquired TV shows are library titles. If anything, as I wrote last spring about 2025, the traditional acquired shows have faded as newer broadcast shows take their place. The F-BOSSS shows, with the exception of The Big Bang Theory this year, don’t dominate the charts like they used to. On one level, this shows the power of Netflix as a platform. If a show leaves Netflix, so does a lot of its viewership. Friends and The Office left Netflix, and now they don’t put up the same gaudy viewership numbers on HBO Max or Peacock (but both do very well for their respective streaming platforms).

What Broadcast Show is Currently Winning?

That’s all to say, many successful broadcast shows will likely have a second life on streaming. Or have a lot of library value, period, so it’s worth checking in every so often to see how they’re doing. We also have to look to broadcast TV, because outside of one very notable exception—The Pitt—the streamers haven’t launched any successful sitcoms or procedurals.

This fall, nearly every broadcast channel put out datecdotes touting how many people are watching their shows cross-platform (live, on DVR/delayed, and on streaming). The broadcasters know that they need to tout multi-platform viewership now, since those additions make the viewership figures a lot larger and help hide the decline in live-linear viewers.

But those numbers are legitimately impressive, as most broadcast shows have millions of viewers on a weekly basis. So let’s review their datecdotes, and then I’ll share some charts from StreamScoop showing the viewership increases:

  • On ABC, 9-1-1’s premiere episode had 8.1 million viewers in its first week, up from the 4.3 million who watched the show the same day. 9-1-1: Nashville had 6.7 million (up from 3.5 million) and Grey’s Anatomy had 5.6 million (up from 2.4 million). Abbott Elementary got nearly four million of its 6.3 million cross-platform viewers.

  • On NBC, Line of Fire, through three episodes, is averaging 6.9 million viewers, with 2 million watching on DVR and 1.8 million on streaming.

  • On CBS, NCIS: New York grew to 10.2 million viewers from 5.6 million (which includes streaming DVR-delayed viewing). Cupertino and Eternally Yours grew to 7.1 million and 6.9 million, respectively. But the big, big shows are Marshals, with 15.1 million viewers, and Tracker, with 13.8 million viewers. (But I didn’t see a breakdown of this viewership.)

One obvious takeaway? CBS is still the boss. CBS even put out a graph touting their ratings compared to streaming shows. Nine of the top ten shows, streaming or linear, were broadcast shows, seven of them from CBS.

In general, I avoid comparing streaming viewership to broadcast shows, because I’d have to make a lot of assumptions to make the comparison apples-to-apples, but these are massive numbers. Again, Marshals has 15.1 million viewers for one episode every week, which would make it the most popular show on streaming week-in and week-out. Adding it up through the year, it would probably best every streaming original.

Again, none of this is new. Viewers have always loved sitcoms and procedurals and other “comfort food” like this. Heck, at the height of cable TV, people were still watching and rewatching old shows! Reruns of sitcoms and procedurals—while not tracked in the ratings like primetime shows—also dominated in syndication. 

This makes the streamers’ lack of success with these genres a problem. The streamers have tried to make new sitcoms over the years, but whether it’s the UX or the quality of the shows, no sitcom has really broken out. In contrast, the streamers haven’t really made a procedural, outside of the aforementioned The Pitt. (This is probably a topic worth a deeper dive at some point.)

So the streamers will need these broadcast shows in the future to power future library content.

Quick Notes on TV

  • Apple TV’s latest show, Nocturne, another crime thriller/mystery with a big-name cast (Liev Schreiber, Zazie Beets and Stephen Graham), missed the Nielsen charts and Samba TV so far, but did make Luminate with 8.0 million hours. It’s coming out weekly, so we’ll see if it pops on the charts in future weeks.

  • Netflix released three new shows, including a sitcom! That sitcom is Minimum Wage, but it will struggle to make the Nielsen charts because it has very, very short episodes, only 16 minutes long. It made Samba TV for one week at tenth place, and missed Nielsen and Luminate so far. Netflix also put out a docu-series on Matthew Perry (titled The One About Matthew Perry) and it actually made it to the top of the Samba TV charts. It also made Luminate with 5.8 and 10.4 million hours, and Nielsen with 9.0 million hours. Given it only had three episodes, that’s a good performance. Netflix also had a foreign docu-series, The Fall of El Mayo, make Luminate with 6.3 million hours and Samba TV at ninth place. For a foreign title, that’s very good. That said, none of these seem like huge hits.

  • Well, Netflix’s Lupin made the Nielsen charts in its second week, with 9.7 million hours. That’s a good jump, especially after I dubbed it a “Miss of the Week” last week. That said, it still hasn’t made the Luminate or Samba TV charts. This one probably isn’t a “miss of the week” anymore, but it’s still far from a hit in America, which is how headlines circa 2022 described it.

  • Crystal Lake on Peacock made it for a third week, but it dropped from its perch as “top debut show on Peacock according to Nielsen’s weekly charts”, to just third place, which is still very, very good. It did fall off both Samba TV and Luminate, but for Peacock this one is absolutely a hit. 

  • Love is Blind on Netflix continues to run below previous seasons, but steady on the Nielsen, Samba TV and Luminate charts. Here’s a comparison to recent outings:

We’re just getting started with this issue, but the rest is for paid subscribers of the Entertainment Strategy Guy, so if you’d like to find out…

  • How Love is Blind stacks up to other recent reality shows…
  • Bespoke data cuts showing how well Tulsa King and VisionQuest performed in their third weeks (surprisingly well!)…
  • How big From jumps in its second week…
  • How Thursday Night Football has dominated October…
  • Minions & Monsters debut on Peacock
  • Bad news for actors…
  • All the flops, bombs and misses…
  • And a whole lot more…

…please subscribe! We can only keep doing this great work with your support.

If you want an idea of just how much content you’d get in a full issue, check out this older issue.

Picture of The Entertainment Strategy Guy

The Entertainment Strategy Guy

Former strategy and business development guy at a major streaming company. But I like writing more than sending email, so I launched this website to share what I know.

Tags

Join the Entertainment Strategy Guy Substack

Weekly insights into the world of streaming entertainment.

Join Substack List